Repository navigation
Count New Jersey foster caretakers and parents of 18-year-old students in the Medicaid parent group - #10984
Conversation
…s in the Medicaid parent group New Jersey's approved state plan S25 (NJ-13-0011-MM1) elects the 42 CFR 435.4 paragraph (3) option counting any adult who lives with a dependent child and assumes primary responsibility for the child's care as a caretaker relative, and the 18-year-old full-time student option. - Add a per-state any-adult caretaker option parameter, true for New Jersey from 2014; where elected, foster children count as dependent children in is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc. - Set New Jersey's dependent-child student option to true from 2014. - Record the S25 / N.J.A.C. 10:69 conflict as a ruled candidate. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
PR Review: Count New Jersey foster caretakers and parents of 18-year-old students in the Medicaid parent groupSummaryThe policy change is correct. I checked the federal rule first, then New Jersey's own texts.
One item needs fixing: the new Critical (must fix)None. Should address
Suggestions
Verified correct
Axiom line assessment
CI statusAll 38 checks pass at head Branch status
Verdict: REQUEST_CHANGES |
DTrim99
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Requesting changes: 0 critical, 1 should address (the ruled candidate us-nj:medicaid-caretaker-relative-any-adult needs a linked ruling record, or state: open), 5 suggestions. Full report in the comment above. The policy itself checks out against 42 CFR 435.4 and NJ S25.
|
Source-conflict ruling (project lead, 2026-11-15): New Jersey's caretaker relative definition follows the approved state plan page S25 (NJ-13-0011-MM1, approved 2014-02-28, effective 2014-01-01). That page elects 42 CFR 435.4 option (3): "any adult with whom the child is living and who assumes primary responsibility for the dependent child's care". It takes precedence over N.J.A.C. 10:69-1.5 and 10:69-3.10(a)1, which list relatives only. |
…into nj-medicaid-caretaker-definition
- us-nj:medicaid-caretaker-relative-any-adult: add the ruling record (by PolicyEngine, 2026-11-15, the project lead's comment on this PR), list this PR under pe_us.prs, and cite N.J.A.C. 10:78-1.1(a), which covers "parents, caretakers and caretaker relatives". - requires_deprivation: New Jersey false from 2014-01-01, citing S25 (NJ-13-0011-MM1, PDF page 31), which eliminates the deprivation requirement from that date. - is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.yaml: assert medicaid_category [PARENT, OLDER_CHILD] on Case 1, the symptom the partner reported ($3,600 / $21,640 = 16.6%, under the 0.34 parent and 1.47 older-child limits), and add Case 4, a New Jersey 18-year-old who is not a student (parent false). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
PR Review (round 2): Count New Jersey foster caretakers and parents of 18-year-old students in the Medicaid parent groupReviewed at head SummaryThe fix commit closes the one open item. It also takes four of the five suggestions.
Prior findings
Should 1, in detail. The candidate now carries
New findingsCriticalNone. Should addressNone. SuggestionsNone. Verified
Axiom
CIAll 37 checks pass at head
I re-checked at the end of the review. Nothing is pending or failing. Branch
Verdict: APPROVE |
Summary
Part of #10775: this PR covers New Jersey, and the issue stays open for other states.
New Jersey's approved state plan page S25 (NJ-13-0011-MM1, approved 02/28/2014, effective 01/01/2014) checks two options for the parent and caretaker relative group (42 CFR 435.110) that the model did not encode:
is_parent_for_medicaid_nfcdropped every child withis_in_foster_carefrom the dependent-child test, so New Jersey adults caring for foster children, including grandmothers caring for foster grandchildren, got the adult group. It also left New Jersey's student option off.Legal basis
Changes
parameters/.../categories/parent/caretaker_relative/any_adult_option.yaml(new)variables/.../categories/parent/is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.pyparameters/.../categories/parent/dependent_child/student_option.yamlparameters/.../categories/parent/requires_deprivation.yamlsource_conflicts/candidates.yamlus-nj:medicaid-caretaker-relative-any-adult(below), with its ruling record.tests/.../categories/parent/is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.yaml(new)Results
is_parent_for_medicaid_nfcfor the adult in each test household, 2026:is_parent_for_medicaid.yaml, which assertis_parent_for_medicaid)In Case 1, $3,600 is 17% of the 2026 poverty guideline for two people ($21,640), under the model's 34% parent group limit for New Jersey, so
medicaid_categorymoves fromADULTtoPARENT; the case asserts[PARENT, OLDER_CHILD]. A New Jersey foster caretaker with income above the parent group's limit stays in the adult group, so Medicaid eligibility for adults aged 19 to 64 doesn't change. New Jersey doesn't cover parents through the medically needy pathway, so that pathway doesn't change.Source conflict
N.J.A.C. 10:69 (AFDC-related Medicaid, readopted effective July 15, 2024) confines the parent role to listed relatives. 10:69-1.5 defines a dependent child as one living "with a parent or other enumerated relative", and 10:69-3.10(a)1 lists the relatives (grandparents, siblings, step-relatives, aunts, uncles, first cousins, nephews and nieces). S25 elects the any-adult option.
The project lead ruled to follow S25. A state elects the 42 CFR 435.4 paragraph (3) option through its state plan, and S25 is the federally approved description of New Jersey's parent and caretaker relative group. N.J.A.C. 10:69 also keeps the deprivation test (10:69-3.15), which S25 removes and the model already leaves out for New Jersey, so the chapter still carries rules the plan has replaced. Grandmothers and other relatives caring for a foster child count as caretakers under both texts.
The ruling record is on this PR. This PR records the conflict as the ruled candidate
us-nj:medicaid-caretaker-relative-any-adultinsource_conflicts/candidates.yaml, with no marker yet (CONTRIBUTING.md, "Source conflicts", step 1).Not changed
is_full_time_student, which also captures full-time college students; nothing populatesis_in_secondary_school(existing comment inis_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.py).Tests
is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.yaml; existing cases unchanged. Expected values traced by hand from 42 CFR 435.4 and S25; not run locally.Review fixes
From DTrim99's review, in commit 29cbb14:
ruling: {by: PolicyEngine, date: '2026-11-15', record: …}with the project lead's ruling comment, lists this PR underpe_us.prs, and cites N.J.A.C. 10:78-1.1(a) (NJ FamilyCare covers "parents, caretakers and caretaker relatives").requires_deprivation: New Jersey false from 2014-01-01, citing S25 page 31.medicaid_category: [PARENT, OLDER_CHILD]; Case 4 adds a New Jersey 18-year-old who is not a student (parent false).axiom: TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2261 queued
🤖 Generated with Claude Code