Skip to content

Require a Medicaid adult group parent's children to have coverage (42 CFR 435.119(c)), with New Jersey's under-21 age - #11012

Merged
hua7450 merged 9 commits into
mainfrom
medicaid-adult-group-child-coverage
Nov 17, 2026
Merged

hua7450 merged 9 commits into
mainfrom
medicaid-adult-group-child-coverage

Conversation

@hua7450

@hua7450 hua7450 commented Nov 16, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Summary

Part of #10776. The requirement now applies in every state; the age limit is sourced for New Jersey and Colorado only, and the issue stays open for the other states' ages.

Builds on #10984 (New Jersey caretaker definition) and #10987 (New Jersey Cover All Kids), both merged; main is merged into this branch.

42 CFR 435.119(c) bars a parent or other caretaker relative from the adult group when a child under the state's age limit, living with them, has no Medicaid, CHIP, Marketplace or other minimum essential coverage. is_adult_for_medicaid_nfc didn't apply it, so a parent with an uninsured child got the adult group.

Legal basis

  • 42 CFR 435.119(c):
    • (1): "A State may not provide Medicaid under this section to a parent or other caretaker relative living with a dependent child if the child is under the age specified in paragraph (c)(2) of this section, unless such child is receiving benefits under Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program under subchapter D of this chapter, or otherwise is enrolled in minimum essential coverage as defined in § 435.4 of this part."
    • (2): "the age specified is under age 19, unless the State had elected as of March 23, 2010 to provide Medicaid to individuals under age 20 or 21 under § 435.222 of this part, in which case the age specified is such higher age."
  • New Jersey approved state plan S32 (NJ-13-0011-MM1), approved 02/28/2014, effective 01/01/2014: "Parents or other caretaker relatives living with a child under the age specified below are not covered unless the child is receiving benefits under Medicaid, CHIP or through the Exchange, or otherwise enrolled in minimum essential coverage". The page selects "Under age 21".
  • Colorado approved state plan S32 (CO-13-0045-MM1), approved 12/18/13, effective 01/01/2014: the same paragraph, with "Under age 19" selected.

Source conflict

42 U.S.C. 1396a(k)(3) reaches only a parent "of a child who is under 19 years of age (or such higher age as the State may have elected) who is eligible for medical assistance under the State plan or under a waiver of such plan". The regulation and both S32 pages reach every child under the age. In the 2012 final rule, CMS called the rule "consistent with the statutory requirements at sections 1902(k)(3)" and wrote that "if a child's pending application is denied for all insurance affordability programs ... the child must be enrolled in other minimum essential coverage for the custodial parent or other caretaker relative to be covered" (77 FR 17144, 17146-17147).

The readings differ only for an uninsured child who is not eligible for Medicaid, such as an undocumented 19-year-old in New Jersey, where coverage regardless of immigration status ends at 19. CONTRIBUTING.md sends a regulation that contradicts its statute to the project lead, who ruled on 2026-11-15 to follow the regulation and S32.

This PR records the conflict as the ruled candidate us:medicaid-adult-group-child-coverage-requirement (follows: conflicting-source) in source_conflicts/candidates.yaml. It adds the requirement file to KNOWN_UNMARKED for its one conflict comment. The # Source conflict marker follows once the rulespec-us entry is on main (CONTRIBUTING.md, "Source conflicts", steps 1 and 3). Case 7 pins the reading.

How the model applies the requirement

  • Who. A non-dependent tax-unit head or spouse living with a tax-unit dependent under the state's age limit. The relationship test, including New Jersey's foster children (Count New Jersey foster caretakers and parents of 18-year-old students in the Medicaid parent group #10984), moves out of is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc into is_child_of_medicaid_caretaker, which both groups now read.
  • Age. The (c)(2) age applies, not the 42 CFR 435.4 dependent-child age of under 18; the 435.4 age would leave (c)(2) without effect. The 435.4 deprivation test doesn't apply.
  • Covered. has_child_coverage_for_medicaid_adult_group is true when any of these holds:
    • the child is enrolled in Medicaid (medicaid_enrolled: eligible and takes up) or CHIP (chip_enrolled);
    • the child can enroll in a Marketplace plan and the tax unit takes up (is_aca_marketplace_enrollee & takes_up_aca_if_eligible);
    • a reported coverage input is true (list parameter qualifying_coverage): has_esi, receives_medicaid, the Medicaid, CHIP, Marketplace, direct-purchase, other means-tested, TRICARE, CHAMPVA and VA *_at_interview inputs, has_health_coverage_other_than_chip or medicare_enrolled. Indian Health Service coverage alone is not minimum essential coverage and isn't listed.
  • No cycle. A child's Medicaid, CHIP and Marketplace status each depend on medicaid_category, which evaluates is_adult_for_medicaid, and so this requirement, for everyone:
    • chip_enrolled → is_chip_eligible_child → ~is_medicaid_eligible;
    • is_aca_marketplace_enrollee → gov.aca.ineligible_coverage → is_medicaid_eligible.
      meets_medicaid_adult_group_child_coverage_requirement therefore reads the children's coverage in a private branch where the requirement is set to met, following medicaid_enrolled_for_ssi_state_supplement and co_adult_financial_medicaid_enrolled. Core checks cycles per branch. The branch changes nothing for the children: only a non-dependent head or spouse is a caretaker, so a tax-unit dependent always meets the requirement. When no caretaker in the simulation lives with a child under the age limit, the formula returns early and creates no branch.

Changes

File Change
parameters/.../categories/adult/child_coverage/age_limit.yaml (new) Per-state (c)(2) age from 2014: New Jersey 21 and Colorado 19, from their S32 pages. The other 49 states carry the federal default of 19, not yet researched.
parameters/.../categories/adult/child_coverage/qualifying_coverage.yaml (new) The coverage sources listed above.
variables/.../categories/parent/is_child_of_medicaid_caretaker.py (new) The caretaker relationship, extracted from is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc unchanged.
variables/.../categories/parent/is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.py Reads is_child_of_medicaid_caretaker; the result doesn't change.
variables/.../categories/adult/has_child_coverage_for_medicaid_adult_group.py (new) Whether a child is covered.
variables/.../categories/adult/meets_medicaid_adult_group_child_coverage_requirement.py (new) The requirement, with the private branch.
variables/.../categories/adult/is_adult_for_medicaid_nfc.py Adds the requirement to the adult group's non-financial test.
source_conflicts/candidates.yaml Adds us:medicaid-adult-group-child-coverage-requirement; adds is_child_of_medicaid_caretaker.py to the code list of #10984's us-nj:medicaid-caretaker-relative-any-adult, since the foster-child line moved there.
tests/code_health/test_source_conflicts.py KNOWN_UNMARKED line for the requirement file (one conflict comment).
tests/.../categories/adult/meets_medicaid_adult_group_child_coverage_requirement.yaml (new) Seven cases.

Results

  1. Each household is one parent with $24,000 of earnings, the amount a Household API partner reported in Medicaid adult group: require a parent's dependent children to have coverage (42 CFR 435.119(c)) #10776, and one child, the parent's tax dependent. $24,000 is 111% of the two-person poverty guideline ($15,960 + $5,680 = $21,640): under the adult group's 138% limit and above New Jersey's 34% parent group limit.
Case State Child Main: parent in adult group This PR
1 NJ 10, enrolled in Medicaid true true
2 NJ 10, Medicaid-eligible but not enrolled, uninsured true false
3 NJ 10, not enrolled in Medicaid, employer coverage true true
4 NJ 21, full-time student, uninsured true true (21 is not under 21)
5 NJ 19, full-time student, Medicaid-eligible through the adult group but not enrolled, uninsured true false
6 CO 19, full-time student, uninsured true true (19 is not under 19)
7 NJ 19, full-time student, undocumented, eligible for no coverage true false

A parent who fails the requirement keeps any other Medicaid category: the parent and caretaker relative group (42 CFR 435.110) has no child coverage requirement and comes before the adult group in medicaid_category. A parent who loses the adult group and has no other category also loses emergency Medicaid through it, since is_emergency_medicaid_eligible needs a Medicaid category. That matches 42 CFR 435.406(b), which pays for emergency services for noncitizens "who otherwise meet the eligibility requirements of the State plan". Above 100% of the poverty guideline, such a parent can become eligible for the premium tax credit.

No existing test should change. A static scan of the YAML tests, partner files included, found uncovered children under 21 living with a working-age adult only in non-expansion states or in cases whose outputs don't depend on the adult's group. One example is the Arizona mixed-status household in emergency_medicaid/integration.yaml Case 12, where the undocumented parent is in the parent group at 106% of the guideline, under Arizona's 111% limit.

Cost

The branch recomputes Medicaid, CHIP and Marketplace eligibility (not taxes, which are already cached) for one year whenever a caretaker in the simulation lives with a child under the age limit, which every microsimulation includes. Cases without such a household skip it. Not measured locally.

Not changed

  • The other 49 states' (c)(2) ages are not researched; a state that covered individuals under 20 or 21 under 42 CFR 435.222 on March 23, 2010 has a higher age.
  • A child who files their own return, such as a 19- or 20-year-old living at home, isn't counted (the parent group's tax-unit proxy).
  • State-funded child coverage modeled outside the Medicaid and CHIP variables, such as Washington Apple Health for Kids (wa_apple_health_kids_eligible, eligibility only, no take-up), doesn't count. California's and New Jersey's state-funded child coverage counts, because the model runs it through medicaid_enrolled.
  • The community engagement requirement from 2027 applies inside the branch as everywhere else: a 19- or 20-year-old New Jersey dependent who fails it isn't enrolled, so their parent fails this requirement.

Tests

  • 7 new YAML cases in meets_medicaid_adult_group_child_coverage_requirement.yaml, expected values traced by hand from the regulation and S32; existing cases unchanged. Not run locally.
  • CI passes

axiom: TheAxiomFoundation/rulespec-us#2285 queued

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

hua7450 and others added 2 commits November 15, 2026 13:52
…s in the Medicaid parent group

New Jersey's approved state plan S25 (NJ-13-0011-MM1) elects the 42 CFR
435.4 paragraph (3) option counting any adult who lives with a dependent
child and assumes primary responsibility for the child's care as a
caretaker relative, and the 18-year-old full-time student option.

- Add a per-state any-adult caretaker option parameter, true for New
  Jersey from 2014; where elected, foster children count as dependent
  children in is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.
- Set New Jersey's dependent-child student option to true from 2014.
- Record the S25 / N.J.A.C. 10:69 conflict as a ruled candidate.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…FR 435.119(c))

A parent or caretaker relative living with a child under the state's
age limit now qualifies for the adult group only if each such child has
Medicaid, CHIP, Marketplace or other minimum essential coverage. The
age limit follows 42 CFR 435.119(c)(2): New Jersey under 21 and
Colorado under 19 from their state plan S32 pages, other states 19
(not yet researched).

- Add meets_medicaid_adult_group_child_coverage_requirement and read it
  in is_adult_for_medicaid_nfc. A child's coverage depends on
  medicaid_category, which evaluates the adult group, so the children's
  coverage is computed in a private branch where the requirement is met.
- Add has_child_coverage_for_medicaid_adult_group: modeled Medicaid and
  CHIP enrollment, Marketplace enrollment with take-up, and a list of
  reported coverage inputs.
- Move the caretaker relationship, including New Jersey's foster
  children, from is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc into
  is_child_of_medicaid_caretaker, shared by both groups.
- Record the statute/regulation conflict as the ruled candidate
  us:medicaid-adult-group-child-coverage-requirement: 42 U.S.C.
  1396a(k)(3) reaches only a Medicaid-eligible child; the project lead
  ruled on 2026-11-15 to follow the regulation and S32.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
hua7450 and others added 2 commits November 15, 2026 22:08
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…caid-adult-group-child-coverage

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@hua7450

hua7450 commented Nov 16, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Source-conflict ruling (project lead, 2026-11-15): us:medicaid-adult-group-child-coverage-requirement

The adult group's child-coverage requirement follows 42 CFR 435.119(c)(1) and the state plan (New Jersey: S32, NJ-13-0011-MM1, age under 21): a parent or caretaker relative living with a child under the (c)(2) age is not covered unless that child receives Medicaid or CHIP or is otherwise enrolled in minimum essential coverage. This applies whether or not the child is eligible for Medicaid. It takes precedence over 42 U.S.C. 1396a(k)(3), which bars the parent only when the child "is eligible for medical assistance" and isn't enrolled.

hua7450 and others added 4 commits November 16, 2026 15:11
…age candidate

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- us-nj:medicaid-caretaker-relative-any-adult: add the ruling record
  (by PolicyEngine, 2026-11-15, the project lead's comment on this PR),
  list this PR under pe_us.prs, and cite N.J.A.C. 10:78-1.1(a), which
  covers "parents, caretakers and caretaker relatives".
- requires_deprivation: New Jersey false from 2014-01-01, citing S25
  (NJ-13-0011-MM1, PDF page 31), which eliminates the deprivation
  requirement from that date.
- is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.yaml: assert medicaid_category
  [PARENT, OLDER_CHILD] on Case 1, the symptom the partner reported
  ($3,600 / $21,640 = 16.6%, under the 0.34 parent and 1.47 older-child
  limits), and add Case 4, a New Jersey 18-year-old who is not a student
  (parent false).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…on' into medicaid-adult-group-child-coverage

# Conflicts:
#	source_conflicts/candidates.yaml
Base automatically changed from nj-medicaid-caretaker-definition to main November 17, 2026 15:37
Main now holds 10984 (squash f6c353c) and 10987. Keep this branch's
is_child_of_medicaid_caretaker refactor in is_parent_for_medicaid_nfc.py,
keep both the caretaker and Cover All Kids entries in candidates.yaml, and
drop 10984's changelog fragment, which main's release already consumed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

hua7450 commented Nov 17, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Codex review summary

Reviewed commit 58d41a2feaf88bfa9383dec09ecb1207aff221ec.

Merge recommendation: yes, with the remaining state age-limit research kept open in #10776 and the required independent review satisfied. No confirmed defects introduced by the current PR were found.

Implementation checks are complete. Policy-source coverage remains partial: New Jersey's under-21 and Colorado's under-19 limits are sourced, while the other states' higher-age elections remain unverified. The default of 19 is a documented provisional value. That remaining research is an explicitly deferred follow-up in #10776.

The earlier college-only student finding is withdrawn from this PR's finding set because the NJ student flag and broad student predicate are already inherited from main through merged #10984. The underlying model issue remains unfixed and needs separate follow-up; this PR's adult-group coverage gate does not introduce the senior parent's existing parent-category result.

The reviewed head has 38 successful CI checks and 7 skipped checks, including successful relevant HHS, household, partner and microsimulation jobs. Focused local calculations used development Core 3.34.10, below the declared 3.36 minimum, and are supporting diagnostics rather than dependency-conforming local test results.

@hua7450
hua7450 merged commit a719b0b into main Nov 17, 2026
45 checks passed
@hua7450
hua7450 deleted the medicaid-adult-group-child-coverage branch November 17, 2026 21:33
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant